Twitter

Sunday 26 January 2014

Siegfried's South African RED WINE Ratings: CODE RED

I have spent years sacrificing my liver for two causes:

ONE: Those who pick grapes depend on me. Whenever I decide whether to open a second bottle, I think of them and their dependents, and my duty is clear.

TWO: Those who know of my extensive chartable work (see ONE above) know that I have spared nothing, not even my liver, for the cause. Many have expressed the fear that my dangerous charity work could result in the loss of the Manuscript, which we can now reveal is named: Code Red.

If one is compelled to drink, whether it be for religious ceremonies or for charitable causes, the wine should at least be decent. Those who pick the grapes would expect nothing less.

To this end, I now share the "fruits" of my labours with others such as your good self. I trust that in exchange for this particular act of kindness, Bacchus might deem it fit to spare my liver for a while longer

 CODE RED will remain on the blog and will be updated every few months or so. 

 Copy the link to your smartphone and it will accompany you to fine restaurants and purveyors of wine wherever you are.

Feel free to comment on later vintages if your efforts to store and drink earlier vintages have ended in ignominious failure.

Email or text me your view and I may include it on here. Why should I be the only scribe who painstakingly interrupts the drinking to make these notes?

NB, do include the date. Some wines improve with age and this is one way to keep a record of that:

 I'm afraid I don't drink Merlot so its mainly Shiraz, Cab Sav, Pinotage and the odd blend:


Andreas Shiraz             2005 ****           12/06/2008

Arendsig Shiraz            2006 ***1/2

Allesverloren Shiraz  2007 *          5 August 2008 barely palatable

Allesverloren Shiraz  2006***         17/05/08

Arabella Cab    2012  3.25*            19/01/2013

Ashton Keldor Shiraz  2005 ***1/2 12/4/08

Boland kelder Shiraz  2006 2.5* too strong coffee taste 11/07/2008

Boland Kelder 2003 Cab Sav 3*

                       2009 Cab Sav 3* 09/01/2013

Boschendal 2005 Shiraz 3 1/2 * Shiraz pleasant

Boschkloof 2004 Cabernet  Savignon 2004 3.75*

Boschrivier 2004 Shiraz 4*  not 2005!

Botha Wynkelder 2005 Shiraz 2* pleasant but no body! OK!

Bovlei shiraz 2003 shiraz 3* 24/06/2008

Cedarberg Shiraz 2006 4* 15/09/2008

Danie de Wet Can Sav 2004  3.75* 7 aug 2008

Darling Cellars 2005 Shiraz woolies reserve 4 1/4 * superb 28/05/2008

Diemersfontein Pinotage 2003

Diemersfontein Cab sav 2003 4*

Drbanville Hills Cab Sav 2006 2* too light. No body

durbanville Hills shiraz 2005 vinegar

Excelsior Shiraz 2005 4*

Fleur de Cap cab sav 2006 * horrible! 14/06/08

Fleur de Cap 2007 Shiraz 2* poor 19/11/09

Glen Carlou 2006 shiraz 4* 5/06/09

Guardian Peak shiraz 2.5*  26\06/08

Hartenburg Cab Sav / Shiraz 2003 3*

                                               2004  3.5*

Hartenburg Cab Sav  2004  4.25* 7/7/08

                                   2005  4.25 25/4/09

Hartenburg shiraz 2005 4.25*  8/7/08 smooth a hint watery..

Hazendal 2003 Shiraz 2* 3/10/08

Hoopenburg Shiraz 2002 5*

Jean Daniel Red blend 2003? very good.

Jordan cab  sav 2005 3.75* 3/7/08

Jordan syrah 2004 4*  3/7/08

Kaapzicht 2005 Shiraz 3* 18/05/2008

Kanonkop Pinotage 1999 4*    5/08/2008        4.75* 16 feb 2009

Kevin Arnold 2005 Shiraz 4*  15/08/2008

Kleine Zalze 2010 Cab Sav 3.75* 13/11/2012 

kloovenburg cab sav 2006 3.5* 28/12/2008

kloovenberg Shiraz 2004 5*

                          Shiraz 2005 5*

Kloovenberg Shiraz  2006 4.5* 01/10/2008

KWV 2007 shiraz vinegar

Laborie cab sav 2004 4* 15/07/08

                cab sav 2006 4* 6/09/2008

Laborie Pinotage 2006  3* 23/07/08

Laibach 2004 cab ** 3/4

La Motte cab 2005 sab sav 5*

La motte cab  sav/ shiraz reseve 2006 (woolies) *** 1/2 17/05/08

Landskroon Shiraz 2006. 3 1/2 *  very pleasant 18/2/08  3* 12/12/08

Landskroon Cab Sav 2006  3.75*  7 Aug 2008

                                2009  3.75* 23 Jan 2011

Le Grande Cappu Pinotage 2011 3.5* 7 Jan '13

Linton Park 2005 cab sav 3.5* 25 june 2009

L'ORMARINS Cab Sav 2002 5*

Lourensford cab sav 3.75* 11/08/2008

Morengenhof cab  sav 2003 2.25* 10/09//2008

Nature in concert (de wet) pINOT nOIR 2007 4* 7/08/2008

Naughton's Flight Shiraz 2005  4* 7/01/09

Nederburg Shiraz 2005 2* 19/03/2008 seems off too sharp!!.

nedeburg cab sav 2001 4* 9/09/2008

Nedeburg cab sav 2006 3*  16/03/2008 questionable aftertaste

Nedeburg cab  sav private bin r163 1999 5*

Neil Joubert Cab Sav 2004 but not 2005

Neil joubert 2005 shiraz **** 14/06/2008 4.5*--13/11/2008 2006 shiraz 3.75 11 july 2009

Neetlingshof Pinotage 2003 4.5 * 21/03/2008

Onyx Shiraz 2004 1 1/2* unpleasant aftertaste

Porcupine ridge 2007 shiraz 3* 11/09/2008

                          2008 shiraz 2.75* 18/06/09

Raka shiraz biography 2005 4.5* 17/07/06

                                   2006 4* 17/06/09

Rietvallei 2006 cab sav 2.75* 22/06/08

Rhebokskloof 2005 Shiraz 3* 12/03/2008

Rupert & Rothschild Baron edmond 2004 blend  4 *

Ruitersvlei shiraz 2004. 12/05/09 3.5* v pleasant.

Rust & vrede cab 2004 3.75* 25/07/2008

Rust 5 vrede  shiraz 2004  4.25* 25/07/2008

Saxenburg shiraz 1994 4* 19/11/2008

                            2005 4* 5/06/2009

Savanha Shiraz 2003 terrible

Simonsig Cab Sav 2004  3.75* 19/02/2013

Simonsig Shiraz 2008 4.5* 15/08/2011

                          2009 4*   17/08/2011

Stellenzicht Pinotage 2006 3.75* 14/08/2008

stellenzicht shiraz 2005 4.25*  16/03/2009

The Berrio cab sav 2005 3.75*  30/01/2009

Tokara zondernaam cab sav 2005 3.75* 28/11/2008

Terra Hutton Cab 2000  5*

Uitkyk cab sav shiraz 2004 2.5* 5/09/2008

Under Oaks 2005  Shiraz  4* 18/03/2009

vilafonte 2004 series m 2004 3.75 10 july 2009

               2004 series c 2004 4.25

               2005  series m 3.25

               2005 series c 4.5

               2006 series c 5:0

Vilafonte 2006 series c  blend 3:75* 10/07/2009

 

Welgegund Cab 2004   3*

Welmoed Shirax 2002  3*

welmoed shiraz 2006 3* 3/07/08

zandvliet shiraz 2005 3* a little sharp. 19/03/08

                                          3.25* 28/06/08

Zandvleit kalveld shiraz 2002 5* 21/04/2008

Zonnebloem Shiraz 2006 3.75 delicious! 22/8/08

Zonnebloem Shiraz 2007 3.25 25 Jan 2011

Zonnebloem 2006 cab sav 2 13/6/2008 poor

                     2008 Cab Sav 2 23 Jan 2011 poor

zonnebloem 2006 pinotage 2.5* 10/06/2008

Viljoensdrift Cab sav river grandeur 2005  3.75* 11/0/08
 
Siegfried Walther  +27 29 6055 828    / 079 6055 828

No comments:

Post a Comment